The financial impact of ESG

How a low ESG score can to lower valuation and higher interest rates

Until a few years ago, a company's valuation was primarily based on its intrinsic value. However, in recent years, Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) factors have increasingly emerged as crucial metrics. They are an integral part of sustainable business practices and long-term value creation. What began as a framework for ethical investing has now evolved into a powerful force shaping financial markets and corporate decision-making. In this blog, we delve deeper into the impact a low ESG score can have on your company, its valuation, and the financing chain.

Banks and financial institutions are at the forefront of this shift. The reason behind this move is clear: companies with strong ESG performance are seen as less risky investments, making them more attractive to lenders. Conversely, companies with low ESG scores may face higher interest rates.

This shift in lending dynamics underscores the financial implications of ESG considerations. Companies that neglect or underestimate their ESG responsibilities not only risk reputational damage but also face economic consequences in the form of higher financing costs and limited access to capital. ESG performance has become a crucial factor determining the financial health and resilience of a company in today's capital markets.

Value enhancement or loss?

Furthermore, the influence of ESG extends beyond the realm of interest rates and also affects company valuations. Investors and analysts are increasingly integrating ESG metrics into their valuation models, acknowledging the effect of environmental and social risks on long-term financial performance. A robust ESG strategy is not just a checkpoint for corporate responsibility; it is a driver of shareholder value and competitive advantage.

Companies that fail to properly translate or manage ESG factors often remain vulnerable in the case of an acquisition or merger. Professional acquirers are also paying more attention to ESG processes and reporting. For them, the absence or inconsistency of these factors is becoming a dealbreaker.

Imagine a scenario with two similar companies operating in the same industry. One company prioritizes sustainability initiatives, minimizes its ecological footprint, promotes diversity and inclusion, and strongly emphasizes employee well-being. The other company, however, lacks a coherent ESG strategy.

When these companies undergo a valuation assessment, the contrast in their ESG performance inevitably influences investor perceptions and market sentiment. A company with a solid ESG track record is likely to receive a higher valuation, reflecting investor confidence in the company's ability to manage risks, seize opportunities, and generate sustainable long-term returns. On the other hand, a company with weak ESG credentials may find its valuation lower, reflecting concerns about operational vulnerabilities and future prospects.

The IPO of meal delivery service Deliveroo was an example of this. The stock lost about a quarter of its value, attributed to the poor working conditions of delivery riders and the negative publicity surrounding them. A poorly rated social factor was thus directly translated into value loss.
 

Extra cost pays off quickly

Implementing new ESG processes can be a long and expensive process if you don't know where to start. But instead of seeing it only as a cost, it is primarily an investment in the future of your company.

A thoughtful ESG policy pays off and makes your company more valuable in the long run. For example, comprehensive reporting will guide your company more quickly towards the right investments to subsequently generate returns. Your ESG policy helps you attract the right profiles, ensuring continuity. And finally, good reporting is a strong negotiating tool when finding and attracting new opportunities. As financial markets continue to prioritize sustainability and regulatory scrutiny increases, integrating ESG into corporate strategy is not just a choice—it's a strategic necessity for long-term success.

Curious about Move To Happiness' ESG implementation plan? Tested and proven effective with more than 7,000 employees from companies like VGD, Accenture, Nyrstar, ... Download our 7-step plan here.